Post
Sun Jan 28, 2007 12:10 pm
nah, solids are more trouble than they're worth on a road car imo. cos they run looser tolerances they'll actually mean you lose a bit of cam profile too, and shimming is annoying, and its a cam-out job on the IS. Unless you're anal and frequently do the clearances, they'll be noisier too. imo hyds are much better, at least they are on a car that's in regular use. my old golf had solids and they were ok and fairly quiet, but not as good as hyds and required maitenence. There are a load of different lifters you can use to fit, the origs aren't supposed to be very good, they're well heavy and allegedly overpump at high rpm (i've never had them in my engine at over 7k so can't verify this). i have lightweight hyd lifters in mine that don't overpump with our oil pressure at high rpm. even the later bmw lifters are a bit lighter and better allegedly (i have loads of spares of these btw!). unless seriously messing with the engine the standard lifters should be fine though. i wouldn't worry too much if going for a 7,2k ish limit and not doing a big bucks rebuild.
simon, using max safe bore for NA would give you 1925cc with m42 crank; you could push the bores more but you'd be nuts to imo. would make a pretty cool short-stroke engine, i'd prefer to go squarer though, depends what characteristics you're looking for i guess.

2.1 318is, MS, LPG. 200bhp, 175ft/lbs GONE!
Boxster, e46 m3, e36 sport touring and alpina B3 3.0