I think the CV joint in my rear driver's side half-shaft is going - can make it clunk at will! As I understand it, the whole half-shaft has to come out. Is that a big job? Will I need a puller? My car has drum brakes, not discs, don't know if that will make any difference. If anyone has a link to an article with step-by-step instructions I would appreciate it.
Ian
Changing rear right-hand half-shaft - what's involved?
Moderator: martauto
-
handpaper
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 883
- Joined: Sun Apr 16, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: Newport, South Wales
Can be easy, can be impossible.
You will need:
Jack and axle stands
8mm allen key
pliers
30mm socket + drive
VERY BIG HAMMER and drift
Slacken the wheel bolts on the appropriate side before jacking the rear of the car up and supporting it on axle stands. With the handbrake on, undo and remove the six allen bolts holding the inner CV joint to the diff. Usually I'd say to support this, but since you're changing the whole unit you might as well let it hang.
Take off the wheel and pull out the locking collar from around the driveshaft nut. It can be teased free with a thin flat screwdriver and needle nosed pliers.
The nut is 30mm and very tight (150 ft-lbs) . Before attempting to remove it, make sure the handbrake is firmly applied and put the car in first gear. It's best done with a 3/4" drive breaker bar, but I've used a 1/2" drive ratchet with a 4ft scaffold pole slipped over it (but then, I'm an animal
) .
Next comes the hard part - you'll need your VERY BIG HAMMER to drift the splined shaft out of the hub. Or maybe you won't. Some of these come out easily, some can't be shifted at all. The bigger your hammer, the better your chances.
To quote Haynes at their least helpful, 'refitting is the reverse of removal'. Once again, the splined shaft is the hard bit, gently tap it in using a soft faced mallet or hammer and wood block on the back of the outer joint. Once a bit of thread shows inside the hub, you can put the nut on and draw the shaft the rest of the way in by doing it up.
Since this is the new shaft, support the inner end while fitting to avoid damaging the joints.
You will need:
Jack and axle stands
8mm allen key
pliers
30mm socket + drive
VERY BIG HAMMER and drift
Slacken the wheel bolts on the appropriate side before jacking the rear of the car up and supporting it on axle stands. With the handbrake on, undo and remove the six allen bolts holding the inner CV joint to the diff. Usually I'd say to support this, but since you're changing the whole unit you might as well let it hang.
Take off the wheel and pull out the locking collar from around the driveshaft nut. It can be teased free with a thin flat screwdriver and needle nosed pliers.
The nut is 30mm and very tight (150 ft-lbs) . Before attempting to remove it, make sure the handbrake is firmly applied and put the car in first gear. It's best done with a 3/4" drive breaker bar, but I've used a 1/2" drive ratchet with a 4ft scaffold pole slipped over it (but then, I'm an animal
Next comes the hard part - you'll need your VERY BIG HAMMER to drift the splined shaft out of the hub. Or maybe you won't. Some of these come out easily, some can't be shifted at all. The bigger your hammer, the better your chances.
To quote Haynes at their least helpful, 'refitting is the reverse of removal'. Once again, the splined shaft is the hard bit, gently tap it in using a soft faced mallet or hammer and wood block on the back of the outer joint. Once a bit of thread shows inside the hub, you can put the nut on and draw the shaft the rest of the way in by doing it up.
Since this is the new shaft, support the inner end while fitting to avoid damaging the joints.
-
Nelly
- Gumbo

- Posts: 4239
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: Divorce Central
-
Dr Firefly
- E30 Zone Doctor

- Posts: 1027
- Joined: Fri Apr 07, 2006 11:00 pm
That all makes pretty good sense. The wheel bearing was only changed 6 months ago, will that make it likely to be an easier job? Thanks for the help, that gives me a good idea about what I'll be doing.
Cheers, Ian
Cheers, Ian
-
handpaper
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 883
- Joined: Sun Apr 16, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: Newport, South Wales
Yep, if the assembly's been apart recently it should be easier.
I did mine two years ago, last year and last month (all the same side). Two years ago, the shaft would not come out for me, so I gave it to a garage with a 10-ton hydraulic puller
. It wouldn't come out for them, either
.
I had to change the whole assembly - shaft, hub, and trailing arm. Lots of fun.
Last year, I had my local breaker fit a replacement as the outer CV joint had split. They managed it, using a sledgehammer
.
After my 'Ring trip, I noticed the same bloody thing had gone again; I found a replacement and fitted it inside half an hour, easy.
I did mine two years ago, last year and last month (all the same side). Two years ago, the shaft would not come out for me, so I gave it to a garage with a 10-ton hydraulic puller
I had to change the whole assembly - shaft, hub, and trailing arm. Lots of fun.
Last year, I had my local breaker fit a replacement as the outer CV joint had split. They managed it, using a sledgehammer
After my 'Ring trip, I noticed the same bloody thing had gone again; I found a replacement and fitted it inside half an hour, easy.
-
Martinaston
- E30 Zone Addict

- Posts: 3749
- Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: London
When you say you can make it klunk at will what do you mean ?
There is NO nucleus.
-
liam012
- E30 Zone Camper

- Posts: 1424
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2005 11:00 pm
would like to know about this clunk business too...
edit - and just out of curiosity martinston do you trawl the froum for posts on driveline shunt?!! you seem to appear whenever it 'could' or does pop up?!
edit - and just out of curiosity martinston do you trawl the froum for posts on driveline shunt?!! you seem to appear whenever it 'could' or does pop up?!

-
Martinaston
- E30 Zone Addict

- Posts: 3749
- Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: London
I think Firefly2005's problem may be the rear bushes not the half shaft.
There is NO nucleus.
-
liam012
- E30 Zone Camper

- Posts: 1424
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2005 11:00 pm
to be honest i still have the clunk on the passenger wheel
but i dont know if the play is everywhere or what;
ie:
a)1st gear on the lift you can rotate prop a small bit - shouldnt it be locked in place by being in gear - if not there must be quite a gap between the teeth of the gears.
b)can rotate the prop a few degrees before the output shafts of the slipper start turning
c)can turn the wheel by hand making it clunk but cannot acertain is it rotational play in the drive shaft - excess backlash in the diff - play in the gearbox
d)some days groan/moan when going round a tight bend at 15 mph/10mphh
e)no whines from diff ever , new clutch packs
i cant afford to replace the whole lot?
and i can figure what should be so bloody simple it out....
maybe i'll just buy a pair of new rear bearings as they're cheap!!
ooops sorry bout the thread hijack but it was answered superbly already
but i dont know if the play is everywhere or what;
ie:
a)1st gear on the lift you can rotate prop a small bit - shouldnt it be locked in place by being in gear - if not there must be quite a gap between the teeth of the gears.
b)can rotate the prop a few degrees before the output shafts of the slipper start turning
c)can turn the wheel by hand making it clunk but cannot acertain is it rotational play in the drive shaft - excess backlash in the diff - play in the gearbox
d)some days groan/moan when going round a tight bend at 15 mph/10mphh
e)no whines from diff ever , new clutch packs
i cant afford to replace the whole lot?
and i can figure what should be so bloody simple it out....
maybe i'll just buy a pair of new rear bearings as they're cheap!!
ooops sorry bout the thread hijack but it was answered superbly already

-
Martinaston
- E30 Zone Addict

- Posts: 3749
- Joined: Mon Mar 14, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: London
A CV joint normaly only makes a noise once its run dry but can work fine with a load of play in it.
Put it in gear and with the wheel on the ground see if you can twist the centre of the half shaft, that will show how worn the CV joints are. If the prop rotates when trying the same thing on there then as you say its gearbox gears and bearings and the diff. Its a process of elimination and replacement, albeit a bloody expensive one
Put it in gear and with the wheel on the ground see if you can twist the centre of the half shaft, that will show how worn the CV joints are. If the prop rotates when trying the same thing on there then as you say its gearbox gears and bearings and the diff. Its a process of elimination and replacement, albeit a bloody expensive one
There is NO nucleus.
-
Dr Firefly
- E30 Zone Doctor

- Posts: 1027
- Joined: Fri Apr 07, 2006 11:00 pm
Well like I say there's a high pitched whining noise (pretty quiet) when the car's coasting under its own momentum, and when I say I can make it clunk, I mean that if I lift up on the power quickly, or put it on quickly, there's a clunk as if slack's been taken up on the drivetrain.Martinaston wrote:amongst other things, it just seems odd no one's nailed it yet
I think Firefly2005's problem may be the rear bushes not the half shaft.
And if you get it right (or wrong, i suppose), you can get a kind of resonance going where the clunks come constantly and the car jerks about all over.
The reason I thought it was the CV joint is that the high pitched whine comes from that side, and when you turn the propshaft by hand, there's a lot of play in the CV joint. And the rubber boot's perished - there's a thin line of oil or grease or something that's been sprayed out over the underside of the car.
What do you reckon symptoms of worn rear bushes would be? Similar stuff?
The whole thing's exaggerated by the fact that I've either got air getting in somewhere it shouldn't, or a failing AFM, as the car pulses when under minor load on the accelerator, and can set off this clunking - mainly when I'm in 2nd gear in heavy traffic, makes it look like I can't drive!
Thanks for the thoughts so far everyone, keep 'em coming,
Ian

