Looooong cranking / intermittent stalling 325i

Need technical Q/A then you're in the right place

Moderator: martauto

rickk
E30 Zone Newbie
E30 Zone Newbie
Posts: 96
Joined: Tue May 10, 2005 11:00 pm
Location: Netherlands, E30-1 325i

Post Thu Jan 18, 2007 8:49 pm

I have the weirdest problem with my '86 325i (Motronic 1.1, no cat):

After sitting for about 4 days, it starts only after cranking a minute (or two..). The engine then splutters for half a minute, fuel smell from the exaust, and then runs fine afterwards. When tow-started, it starts almost immediately.

- When this happened, I replaced the main and fuel pump relays.
- Cleaned contacts, checked ground points
- Also checked all sensors with a multi-meter, read fine.

After a few occasions of this, and after the car started fine (for a change), it suddenly died about 1 minute after startup when driving slowly, downshifting to 2nd and completely refused to restart. :mad:
A road-side diagnosis showed that there was no spark neither from the plug nor from the coil. Started right up again after tow-starting.

- So I replaced the notorious speed and reference sensors

After this, it soon stalled again, again driving slowly, a minute after startup, when downshifting to 2nd. Wasn't able to diagnose it that time. Eventually got it tow-started (took quite a bit longer this time) again.

- so I replaced to coil
- ... and the ECU

Car didn't stall on me after that.. In fact, I was pretty much convinced the problem was solved. But now, after sitting for a few days.... :x It took ages of cranking to start the car again. Back to square one! :cry:

I'm pretty much at a loss diagnosing this problem. The fact that it only appears after sitting for a few days or at random (cutting out), and (ofcourse) only when you really don't have the time to diagnose it doesn't really speed up the process.

Summarizing:

- replaced speed/ref sensors, coil, ECU, fuel relay, main relay
- checked and cleaned contacts (will do this again)
- if it runs, runs as normal, pulls strong, etc.
- took loads of bumpy roads suspecting a bad contact somewhere. doesn't cut out whatever I try to do.
- when it cuts out, or refuses to start, tach seems to track engine RPM, indicating that the ECU at least has power and a speed signal
- when it cuts out, it's just like someone cut the ignition. no splutter or anything, just dead.
- when it cuts out, there's no spark from the coil (verified once, will need to verify again)
- tow-starting gets it running again
- after cranking for a loooooong time, exhaust smells of fuel
- battery is a few months old, very strong, as it supports cranking the car for minutes..

I'll re-diagnose everything again ASAP, but for now I suspect I'm still not getting a spark from the coil during these long cranking sessions.

Anyone any clues? I'm pretty much at a loss... :cry: [/i]
User avatar
eltel
E30 Zone Regular
E30 Zone Regular
Posts: 654
Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2005 11:00 pm
Location: mid wales

Post Fri Jan 19, 2007 5:52 pm

this sounds exactly like what happened to me...after long cranking the exhaust will smell of fuel as the cylinders will fill up and not burn it off...

i'd check the crankshaft sensor as this cured mine...if this is failing there will be no spark.
mine had chaffed on the water pump pulley and gave intermittant trouble for weeks until it finally rubbed through totally.

it sits on driver side of engine held by one allen key bolt and routes up through the front pulleys to a multiplug under engine diagnostic port on pass side.
Only in the good lord we trust.. In everything else we check!!


1988 325i Tourer, Lowered, Deep Dish Alloys, Obc, Cruise Control, Heated Leather Sport Seats....
Ant
Retired Team Member
Retired Team Member
Posts: 10496
Joined: Tue Dec 21, 2004 11:00 pm
Location: PD+E dept :D

Post Fri Jan 19, 2007 6:15 pm

Eltel, the early cars use two ref sensors in the gearbox dude, but your info is 100% for the post '88 rides :thumb:

That is a very expensive list of new parts, one item missing is a new DME relay, it can and will cause all the symptoms you're suffering, replace it ASAP and have another go.

located, left hand inner wing, where the strut is, under black cover, there are two relays in there, one has 4 pin= fuel pump, the other has 5, that is the DME relay.

HTH
Product Development and Endurance for Delphi.

Original performance chips, original works not unlicensed copies :D Email FTW