m50engine swap been told diffrent thing

[sx_pete]

hi ya'al
right i want to do an m50 engine conversion on my bmw compact

but i've been told that because my car is 1999 (v reg) that is obd2 and a m50 engine is obd1so it's not possible ( i think it's some thing to do with wiring not sure).
My problem is I've seen it done

can anyone give in any help/input if this is true

thanks in advance

[HairyScreech]

It is possible, however it's not worth it. I am sure he is referring to EWS rather than OBD as obd will make no odds.
As you have EWSII you can go for an m52b28 of the same age and just swap all of the EWSII components over from the donor car, an m50 conversion would mean converting back to an older version of the imobliser and actually a 2.8 m52 is a better choice.

[DanThe]

The EWS is easily dealt with if its a later vanos engine, apart from that its just a case of bridging 2 wires

[leeparkes]

Being a late 99 car it will be EWS3

[sx_pete]

so if i fit ecu, loom, engine, box, something like this

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Single-Vanos- ... 4ac59a46c7

and then got the ews deleted off the ecu

plug and play?

i know you guys are right in the m52 being a little better easier
i want the m50 for a turbo project as i still have most bits from my 200sx

[BATTS91]

like said above your car will probably be ews3 .
better off with m52b28!

and you will have ews issues if you dont know what your doing to cut and shut them , its not as simple as putting an m52 with ews into an e30 .

I do know someone that can offer his services to correct this for you depending on your location .

[leeparkes]

iirc it will be an easier swap with an early M50 as EWS wont be involved, ie nothing to stop the engine running.
If EWS is an issue could it be run on E36 323i management? in theory there both 2.5 litre vanos engines.

[sx_pete]

I do know someone that can offer his services to correct this for you depending on your location .

location = Warrington n/w of England cheers

[Rav335uk]

Why bother???

[leeparkes]

i want the m50 for a turbo project

[Rav335uk]

i want the m50 for a turbo project

M30 prduces better Turbo results on standard internals, a proven 500 BHP

[leeparkes]

Its going in a compact Rav.

[Rav335uk]

and.......
I would like to see something different Lee rather than "run of the mill" in a compact.

[DanThe]

so if i fit ecu, loom, engine, box, something like this

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Single-Vanos- ... 4ac59a46c7

and then got the ews deleted off the ecu

plug and play?

i know you guys are right in the m52 being a little better easier
i want the m50 for a turbo project as i still have most bits from my 200sx

That will be a non EWS engine already, you wont need to touch the ECU, just get the starter working and your away

[joeyb]

so if i fit ecu, loom, engine, box, something like this

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Single-Vanos- ... 4ac59a46c7

and then got the ews deleted off the ecu

plug and play?

i know you guys are right in the m52 being a little better easier
i want the m50 for a turbo project as i still have most bits from my 200sx

The seller is also a zoner (if you weren't already aware)