E30 318 auto box problem
Moderator: martauto
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hi all, my car has just recently developed a problem with its auto box, (the fluid level is fine and there are no leaks), when driving along it would normally change gear around 10 mph, then around 23 mph, then another change at around 32mph, then when it hit around 57mph it would seem to change again, but now it doesnt do this change at around 57, and when it hits over 60 it quite often seems to like surge a bit, like its trying to change but doesnt, if i back off the accelerator then the surging stops but still doesnt change gear.
I recently drove it to devon, around 160 miles, drove it around for 3 days (lots of very steep hills), and it was on the homebound journey that this started, so i am confused as to what this problem is.
now when i start her up from cold it stays in first and doesnt change, i either have to pull over for a minute, or keep backing off the accelerator until it changes, also the gear changes arent so noticable now.
it drives me nuts as the car was perfect before this long journey to devon. and fine during our time down there.
any help will be appreciated
si
Hi all, my car has just recently developed a problem with its auto box, (the fluid level is fine and there are no leaks), when driving along it would normally change gear around 10 mph, then around 23 mph, then another change at around 32mph, then when it hit around 57mph it would seem to change again, but now it doesnt do this change at around 57, and when it hits over 60 it quite often seems to like surge a bit, like its trying to change but doesnt, if i back off the accelerator then the surging stops but still doesnt change gear.
I recently drove it to devon, around 160 miles, drove it around for 3 days (lots of very steep hills), and it was on the homebound journey that this started, so i am confused as to what this problem is.
now when i start her up from cold it stays in first and doesnt change, i either have to pull over for a minute, or keep backing off the accelerator until it changes, also the gear changes arent so noticable now.
it drives me nuts as the car was perfect before this long journey to devon. and fine during our time down there.
any help will be appreciated
si
-
TPS
- E30 Zone Team Member

- Posts: 13119
- Joined: Fri Mar 06, 2009 11:00 pm
- Location: Hampshire
Fluid Change?

1991 325i Touring Alpine White II
1994 318i Touring Sterling Silver
-
greg124
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 668
- Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 11:00 pm
- Location: In the pub
Maybe all the hills in Devon cooked the fluid.
I'd try a fluid change before doing anyhting else.
I'd try a fluid change before doing anyhting else.
Schadenfreude - the German's haven't got a word for that.
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
Cheers lads, is there any sort of control device for gear selection on my car, i have read up on e36 gear boxes and water getting into these devices (cant remember its name sorry) which can cause probs, just wanna find out if mine has one and check for water
-
Andyboy
- Alpina Colada
- Posts: 12577
- Joined: Mon Sep 11, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: Notts
The gearbox in these is a sort of five speed. It has four speeds, plus a torque converter lock up at @55 mph. This locks the converter solid to provide a direct drive for economy. It sounds like the converter lock up clutch had broken up and bits of it are swimming round the box.
Give the fluid a sniff - it should be cherry red. If it's black/brown and smells burned then the gearbox is kaput. Hanging on the first gear is a sign that the gearbox is shagged - it's bits of gearbox clogging up the governor. By all means try a fluid and filter change (well, clean the filter with brake cleaner - don't buy a new one yet) and see if that does anything. I doubt it will though. It's a 20 year old autobox which has probably had enough. When the sump is dropped, expect to find a lot of grey sludge inside.
Give the fluid a sniff - it should be cherry red. If it's black/brown and smells burned then the gearbox is kaput. Hanging on the first gear is a sign that the gearbox is shagged - it's bits of gearbox clogging up the governor. By all means try a fluid and filter change (well, clean the filter with brake cleaner - don't buy a new one yet) and see if that does anything. I doubt it will though. It's a 20 year old autobox which has probably had enough. When the sump is dropped, expect to find a lot of grey sludge inside.
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
cheers andy, will try a fluid change first, i doubt the box has had it coz its only done 68k and has an extensive history, the fluid was first changed around 30k, but i wont hold my breath on the fluid change till its done and i see it working, is a fluid change an easy job? what parts should i expect to buy? and what grade or brand of fluid is recomended? also is there a write up on how to change fluid?
Sorry about all the questions but it pains me that my car is playing up
Sorry about all the questions but it pains me that my car is playing up
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
I forgot to add that i drove it yesterday whilst trying to figure out the problem, i gave it some welly and it did actually engage into this sort of fifth gear, but that was giving it some beans though, and i dont drive like that, but it did change into it though, which makes me hope its just fluid
-
greg124
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 668
- Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 11:00 pm
- Location: In the pub
Changed the fluid in mine last week. It's a fairly easy job, but much easier if you can get the car off the ground (axle stands under the front end).
It is recommended to change the filter - as mentioned above (along with its little round seal) and the pan gasket. When I changed mine last week I found GSF had supplied the wrong pan gasket, so re-fitted the old one, and it doesn't seem to leek. So, while you're investigating the problem I should forget about these items for now.
You will need 3 litres of Dextron 2 ATF - Automatic Transmission Fluid.
Undo the pan drain plug with an allen key to drain most of the fluid, then undo the big nut (30mm spanner, from memory) at the bottom of the dipstick tube, and the six nuts around the edge of the pan - there may still be more fluid in this. Clean any gunge out of the pan, and examine the two small magnets in the bottom for any small metal bits that may have become detached from the inner workings. When everything is scrupulously clean, replace the pan and do up the 6 nuts, taking care not to over-tighten them - it doesn't take much to shear them (as I found out!). Refit the drain plug. Re-attach the dipstick tube and tighten the big nut.
With a funnel, refill slowly through the dipstick tube.
Start the engine, move the selector through all the gears, then check the fluid level.
Test drive, and if all is well, open a beer.
Good luck
It is recommended to change the filter - as mentioned above (along with its little round seal) and the pan gasket. When I changed mine last week I found GSF had supplied the wrong pan gasket, so re-fitted the old one, and it doesn't seem to leek. So, while you're investigating the problem I should forget about these items for now.
You will need 3 litres of Dextron 2 ATF - Automatic Transmission Fluid.
Undo the pan drain plug with an allen key to drain most of the fluid, then undo the big nut (30mm spanner, from memory) at the bottom of the dipstick tube, and the six nuts around the edge of the pan - there may still be more fluid in this. Clean any gunge out of the pan, and examine the two small magnets in the bottom for any small metal bits that may have become detached from the inner workings. When everything is scrupulously clean, replace the pan and do up the 6 nuts, taking care not to over-tighten them - it doesn't take much to shear them (as I found out!). Refit the drain plug. Re-attach the dipstick tube and tighten the big nut.
With a funnel, refill slowly through the dipstick tube.
Start the engine, move the selector through all the gears, then check the fluid level.
Test drive, and if all is well, open a beer.
Good luck
Schadenfreude - the German's haven't got a word for that.
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
cheers greg, you're a good un, will have to wait till a week saturday till i get a day off, will try it then, am i right in thinking that you only get a true reading from the dipstick when the fluid is warm and the engine is still on or have i been given the wrong info?
-
Andyboy
- Alpina Colada
- Posts: 12577
- Joined: Mon Sep 11, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: Notts
Look at the fluid on the dipstick. If it's still a nice pinky red colour, there's no point in changing it. Hanging onto first gear is 101% a governor problem - ask any automatic gearbox specialist. These have centrifugal weights which stick when there's enough grey sludge inside the unit, and the grey sludge is bits of clutch ring. 68'000 miles is nothing - I've known these boxes to fail after 30'000 miles. I can guarantee you that when you drop the sump, you'll find a lot of grey sludge on the magnets. The filters on the 4HP22 are nothing like as efficient as what was used on the later 5 speed boxes.
Also, this problem is most common after a long run.
Also, this problem is most common after a long run.
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
so how much do you think i could be looking at to put this right?
-
Andyboy
- Alpina Colada
- Posts: 12577
- Joined: Mon Sep 11, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: Notts
It's either a gearbox rebuild or a good used unit. A full rebuild with a converter is going to be £1200+ by anyone decent, so a used box is the more cost effective way. I'd say £100 for a used box from someone here, replace the converter oil seal, sump gasket and filter, £150-200 labour to fit it (make sure the garage engage the converter lugs into the oil pump properly!).
One last roll of the dice - disconnect the kickdown cable from the throttle lever, and try it again. If it's too tight, it'll be reluctant to go into top gear. I doubt that's the problem, but it costs you nothing but 10 minutes of your time.
One last roll of the dice - disconnect the kickdown cable from the throttle lever, and try it again. If it's too tight, it'll be reluctant to go into top gear. I doubt that's the problem, but it costs you nothing but 10 minutes of your time.
-
si_c
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 9
- Joined: Fri Jul 08, 2011 11:00 pm
cheers again for the advice buddy, and that brings up a good point, before i went away i didnt have time to check over the car, so i asked my bro to do it, he said he put a little spray grease on the end of the throttle cable and thought that the kickdown cable was slack so he tightened it up, so i will check tonight if its too tight or just back it off a little to see what happens
-
Andyboy
- Alpina Colada
- Posts: 12577
- Joined: Mon Sep 11, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: Notts
The kickdown cable is meant to be slightly slack............
Hopefully this is the problem. Fingers crossed etc.
Hopefully this is the problem. Fingers crossed etc.
-
greg124
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 668
- Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 11:00 pm
- Location: In the pub
The 'box things it's permanently in kick-down, so it won't change up.
Sounds like you've found the cause of your problem.
I would still check the colour of the fluid though...
Sounds like you've found the cause of your problem.
I would still check the colour of the fluid though...
Schadenfreude - the German's haven't got a word for that.
