Which one Would you pick

[e30ata]

been offered to get my old motor back for the second time,lovely 525 Sport 70k FSH,but still unsure what to do, he's willing to swap for my touring which i love the look off, unsure what to do, What do u think

[goldysingh]

I'd keep the touring

looks better and probably worth more

I do love the look of your touring

[Cloggy Saint]

Personally, I'd take the 5.

[johnt0709]

Touring purely because I dont like the look of the old 5s - I dont think its iconic, classic - whatever you want to call it - I think they look like big underpowered buses.

[maf260]

From a value perspective the touring is probably worth more now and in the future. The 525 will end up in the low £100s as it's not a desirable model.

[davpkav]

Keep the Touring. No question.

[fuzzy]

525's are 10 a penny and worth not much more then scrap value.

[town325i]

A calypso touring is a rare thing from what ive read on here there are only 3 in this country so if it was me i would keep the e30.

[Blitz]

Thats a very tidy 525i sport with Alpina's. I'd got with that.

[e30ata]

Thats a very tidy 525i sport with Alpina's. I'd got with that.

thats the thing its so clean you could say its immaculate,and my touring needs a few things to be sorted,its a difficult decission suppose to be exchanging on wednesday

[toby]

The touring is far more desirable than the 5. Although the 5 looks cool, it isn't as practical or as much fun to drive generally. Far more comfortable though I suppose.

I couldn't give that calypso touring away.

[RM2186]

I agree Atta, I think I would miss the Touring a lot more. Just bung an M50 into the Touring

[madaboutthe30]

touring

[snakebrain]

Yeah, I like E34s but I like that touring of yours a lot more! It was up for sale for a bit a while ago, yeah? I remember being tempted!!

[gooner1]

I,d be asking myself " why does he want to swap ", and i don,t mean there must be something
wrong with the 525
Think you,d miss the Touring more than he,d miss the 5.
Both very nice looking cars though.

[toecutter666]

I've got both and i can say i like the feel of the e30 over the e34 even though its done 3 x as many miles and looks like ray charles parked it

[RM2186]

I've got both too, which is why I fancy the 525 engine in the E30

[casper8r]

Is the 5 for sale and if so - how much does he want for it?

[e30ata]

I,d be asking myself " why does he want to swap ", and i don,t mean there must be something
wrong with the 525
Think you,d miss the Touring more than he,d miss the 5.
Both very nice looking cars though.

The only reason he's getting rid as he can use this for his tropical fish business ,saves him buying an extra vehicle,
Got to say the 525 is more comfortable,and does drive a dream.
Saying that love the tourer,and if i do let it go i know I'll be in

[RM2186]

Swap it for the silver auto Atta

[e30ata]

Saying that my AC Schnitzer S3 2.7 will be ready in the next couple of months

[e30ata]

Is the 5 for sale and if so - how much does he want for it?

If he doesn't do the deal with me ,he's going to put it up for £2500

[dapperdan8001]

Its a tuff one but not always down to how much money you can make. Bet your heart is saying e30 and head is saying 525.

Good luck with your decision fella.

[fingerman]

Get the Sport and ask this question on a 5 series forum

[love30]

Alpinas!!!!

[e30ata]

Alpinas!!!!

They sure are makes the motor IMO.

[BMJG]

touring only going up in value the 5 will not there dead in the water or dropping

[casper8r]

Is the 5 for sale and if so - how much does he want for it?

If he doesn't do the deal with me ,he's going to put it up for £2500

Oof, a bit steep that (this is not meant as a derisory remark however), not many e34's go for that much.

That being said - they're both great cars, at the end of the day is what YOU like best and what suits your needs.

[jaymos]

bloody hell ata how many cars have you got?

[tomson]

Depends what donk the Touring has?

The E34 does look clean but a 525i is not a highly desireable model and it wont be going anywhere quickly @ £2.5K IMO...

[Alex]

very hard choice, i think i would end up with that touring though just because of the rarity, it would need 24v though

[Blitz]

Is that touring a 316i?

[Alex]

318i i think

[tomson]

If it is then the E34's value is probably higher, rare colour or not!

[Alex]

Ata i know your trying to sell the touring, why dont you contact Old colonels i recon they would offer you a good price for it