I'm posting this tale just in case it is of any use to anyone - if nothing else, you may encourage you not to give up on a problem.
The story:
I decided to restore my original 318is which had been standing for about 4 years with little or no use but had been well looked after previously with all work being done by BMW dealers and big items like steering racks, fuel tanks etc being replaced shortly before I mothballed the car.
The first item to be replaced was a drivers side front wheel bearing/hub, followed by a full set of disks and pads. Soon after fitting the new brakes, I started to get a bad judder through the steering wheel. My local garage advised that the problem was due to wear in the control arm bushes which were replaced (along with the arb drop links and rear axle bushes these failed the mot) but to no avail. The problem was eventually diagnosed by a bmw specialist garage as a warped passenger side disk caused by a partially seized caliper.
The caliper was replaced, along with a new set of disks and a passenger side wheel bearing / hub (to be sure as the old one was starting to go). I fitted the disks that were taken off on to my second car which proved that they had definately been warped.
All was well for about 8 weeks until a similar judder returned when braking. As the original faulty parts had been replaced, the obvious conclusion was that the problem was now being caused by the other obvious suspects such as ball joints, steering u/j etc. The car was re-checked by a couple of garages to see if there were any problems with the suspension / steering or brakes but nothing was found to be wrong. On the off chance that the replacement disks were simply faulty, I managed to get these replaced (this time with bmw rather than ate parts). Feeling pretty tired with the whole thing, I thought f**k it, and also replaced the driver side caliper, just in case this was the culprit on this occassion.
Over the following few weeks the judder returned. At this point, I seriously thought about scrapping the car for spares for my second car but decided to stick with it as I had owned the car for a long time and spent thousands on it over the years.
In the meantime, the car had also been fitted with new front and rear shocks / springs as part of the original restoration project.
Obviously at this point, I am completely confused, as the car now has all new items, nothing can be found to be faulty but I'm still getting the judder when braking. As the new disks and pads were bmw items, I took the car to the local dealers to get these checked under warranty. The dealer diagnosed a warped drivers side alloy wheel but did'nt check anything else. Feeling a bit annoyed that I had paid a labour charge for nothing (the car had been previously tested with two seperate sets of alloys) I swapped all four alloys for the other set I had in the garage and booked the car back in as the fault was obviously still there. This time, they carried out a full run out check on the disks and hubs and found that the passenger side hub (which I had replaced after the first fault) was out of true even though the bearings were fine. As a result, this was causing the disk to run unevenly through the caliper, creating the judder and eventually killing the disk.
This has now been replaced and re-checked, the disks have been replaced as a warranty claim (as part of an apology for not checking things first time it was in) and all seems to be A1 (no surprise given the amount of time and money spent).
Year long braking judder - finally solved!
Moderator: martauto
-
MadE30mike
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 668
- Joined: Mon Jul 17, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: FIFE(Scotland)
-
EOS
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 215
- Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: Eastwood - Essex
Love this forum, just a wealth of information. I would have never thought about checking that
Glad you got it sorted after all that.
-
Brianmoooore
- E30 Zone Team Member

- Posts: 49360
- Joined: Mon Jan 10, 2005 11:00 pm
Interesting story, but for 90% of you out there with juddering from the front end, the problem will be control arm bushes.
Story also illustrates that you should never assume a new part is a good part.
Story also illustrates that you should never assume a new part is a good part.
-
Falkster
- Engaged to the E30 Zone

- Posts: 5787
- Joined: Fri Sep 30, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: Yorkshire
Doesnt it annoy you when that happens?? Had the same on my M3, spent a fortune replacing parts and still had it a year before noticing it was a faulty tyre that had a flat spot!! Never thought to check the tyres because they were brand new. So I got the tyre replaced but it did cost me a wheel bearing due to the vibration
-
Cava
- E30 Zone Regular

- Posts: 349
- Joined: Sat Nov 19, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: South Wales
Could'nt agree more - one of the biggest problems I had, is that everyone automatically dismissed the new parts as being the cause and just ended up guessing on which other old item could be responsible (and replacedԚ£Ã”šÃ‚£Ãƒ”šÃ‚£). I kind of got the impression that a lot of garages just ended up guessing rather than looking at the list / timeline of parts fitted that I provided. The hub run out check idea ended up being made from a conversation in my garage with my father!Brianmoooore wrote:Story also illustrates that you should never assume a new part is a good part.
-
gareth
- E30 Zone Team Member

- Posts: 11005
- Joined: Tue Jan 11, 2005 11:00 pm
- Location: hastings, east sussex
unfortunately (and with no disrespect meant to any on here
) most mechanics aren't the brightest bulbs in the box! problem tracing logic seems to be a hardship and most resort to random parts swapping until the problem goes away!
a good garage (especially any dealer) should have tested the disk (on the hub) for runout with a mag base DTI. if runout is present, the hub should then be tested. unfortunately testing like this takes a few minutes and involves knowhow and most garages will just throw new bits on to see if the problem goes away. hey it's only your money, not theirs!
a good garage (especially any dealer) should have tested the disk (on the hub) for runout with a mag base DTI. if runout is present, the hub should then be tested. unfortunately testing like this takes a few minutes and involves knowhow and most garages will just throw new bits on to see if the problem goes away. hey it's only your money, not theirs!
Sole founder of Fe2O3-12V it's a lifestyle

LSD rebuilding / modification services provided, PM for details

LSD rebuilding / modification services provided, PM for details

