just after info/advise on the seal on the liftout panel of a baur roof,it doesnt leak water but gets a whistle up at speed.
is this seal a replacement part or is there some other way of quietening this down,any help appreciated
baur top seal question
Moderator: martauto
- aretha
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 148
- Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: near Romsey, Hampshire
Hi
I'm no expert - but I've got a Baur. The original centre section on mine does not whistle, but I bought a second hand one which clearly does not fit so well, and it's got a dent in the metal bit on the very front and this one whistles very loudly. There is nothing wrong with the seals on this one and they are better than my original.
We're going to try to straighten the dent to see if this eliminates the whistle but even so, it's evident that this section does not fit so well, ie not flush.
Could it be that yours has a slight dent somewhere? Or is it a replacement section?
As an aside, I've also noticed that in some conditions, not necessarily windy, with rear section down and middle section out, that there is some noise, but this is not all the time.
I've not found a way to quieten it, but maybe someone else has.
There's a real Baur expert on here and I'm sure he'll reply to your question. Sorry I cannot be of more help. Jackie
I'm no expert - but I've got a Baur. The original centre section on mine does not whistle, but I bought a second hand one which clearly does not fit so well, and it's got a dent in the metal bit on the very front and this one whistles very loudly. There is nothing wrong with the seals on this one and they are better than my original.
We're going to try to straighten the dent to see if this eliminates the whistle but even so, it's evident that this section does not fit so well, ie not flush.
Could it be that yours has a slight dent somewhere? Or is it a replacement section?
As an aside, I've also noticed that in some conditions, not necessarily windy, with rear section down and middle section out, that there is some noise, but this is not all the time.
I've not found a way to quieten it, but maybe someone else has.
There's a real Baur expert on here and I'm sure he'll reply to your question. Sorry I cannot be of more help. Jackie
-
bobcat
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 35
- Joined: Sun Oct 04, 2009 11:00 pm
- Location: mid north coast australia
THANKS ARETHA mine is very straight and a good fit ,when it is closed it sits flush with its surrounding,the rubber seal around the opening has a ratty area in it,iwas wondering if this would contribute and whether these are readily available
- aretha
- E30 Zone Newbie

- Posts: 148
- Joined: Sat Nov 18, 2006 11:00 pm
- Location: near Romsey, Hampshire
Hello Bobcat - I suppose it could do and seems the most obvious reason for the noise. In answer to your question, here's a cut/paste response from Cotwold BMW who is the BMW trader on here. Someone else has asked for the seals, whether this includes the one you need, I don't know. Probably worth asking for a quote, but I suppose, postage to sunny Australia is going to be expensive.
You could buy a secondhand one which may or may not be any better. Good luck and I hope you cure the whistle. Jackie
Cotswoldbmw
Trader
Trader
Joined: Sep 15, 2008
Posts: 1614
Location: Cheltenham
Back to top
PostPosted: Tue Aug 04, 2009 11:02 pm Reply with quote
Hi There
as far as i can tell there are 3 seals on rear
Total for all 3 £125.71
Prices inc. VAT delivered to mainland UK
Please call us on 01242 257999 and quote 55239
There is a P&P cost of £1.99 on all orders under £20
Thanks
Brett
_________________
Cotswold Motor Group
01242 257999
partscheltenham@cotswoldgroup.com
www.cotswoldgroup.com
Shop on-line @ www.cotswoldstore.com
You could buy a secondhand one which may or may not be any better. Good luck and I hope you cure the whistle. Jackie
Cotswoldbmw
Trader
Trader
Joined: Sep 15, 2008
Posts: 1614
Location: Cheltenham
Back to top
PostPosted: Tue Aug 04, 2009 11:02 pm Reply with quote
Hi There
as far as i can tell there are 3 seals on rear
Total for all 3 £125.71
Prices inc. VAT delivered to mainland UK
Please call us on 01242 257999 and quote 55239
There is a P&P cost of £1.99 on all orders under £20
Thanks
Brett
_________________
Cotswold Motor Group
01242 257999
partscheltenham@cotswoldgroup.com
www.cotswoldgroup.com
Shop on-line @ www.cotswoldstore.com
